Topic Edit: 처음보는 아시안에게 백인이 Do you speak English?라고 물어보는게 Racism인가?

This topic has [34] replies, 0 voices, and was last updated 2 years ago by tracer.

Now Editing “처음보는 아시안에게 백인이 Do you speak English?라고 물어보는게 Racism인가?”

Name *

Password *

Topic Title (Maximum Length 80)

Hiking Trail입구 주차장에서 차 세우고 picnic area에 잠시 있다가 다시 차로 돌아가고 있는데 옆쪽에서 Hello?하는 소리가 나서 나한테 얘기하는 소린지도 모르고 그냥 계속 걸어갔는데 백인여자가 따라오더니 Do you speak English?하더니 Trail에 Tick이 있으니 차에 들어가기전에 몸을 털라고 하더라구요. 유니폼을 입진 않았지만 분위기를 보니까 Ranger인거 같은데 그런 조언을 해준것이 그 사람 의무이고 고마워해야할걸 알고있지만 이상하게 기분이 나쁘더라구요.
그래서 내가 피해의식있나?라는 생각을 해보다가 내가 영어 한마디도 안 뱉은 상태에서 그런 소리했다는게 이상해서 chatGPT랑 BingChat에 물어봤습니다.

chatGPT
As an AI language model, I do not have personal beliefs or opinions. However, using the phrase "Do you speak English?" in a certain context, such as assuming that someone from Asia or any other region does not speak English solely based on their appearance or ethnicity, could be considered discriminatory or racist. It is important to treat all individuals with respect and not make assumptions about their language abilities based on their appearance, nationality, or ethnicity. It is always best to communicate with others in a respectful and inclusive manner, regardless of their background or ethnicity.

BingChat
Asking “Do you speak English?” to Asians can be considered a racist comment as it implies that Asians are not expected to speak English well. This comment can be seen as a form of linguistic stereotyping that applies even when those Asians are native speakers of English. It can also reduce their American identity. It is important to be aware of these issues and avoid making such comments.

여러분 생각은 어떤가요? 제가 백인남자였다면 그런소리 했을까요?

I agree to the terms of service