-
Assumptions:
- HDPD – maximum out-of-pocket expenses $5,300 for family
- PPO – maximum out-of-pocket expenses $4,000 for family
- PPO in this comparison is “middle level” amongst the PPOs from my employer. HDPD has similar coverage with this PPO.
- This cost comparison does not include benefits of HSA e.g. employer’s contribution
Use Cases:
(1) A family of 4 (2 adults, 2 young children) whose all members have frequent visits to hospitals, urgent cares, and have surgeries.
- HDPD – premium $2,000 + out-of-pocket $5,300 = total $7,300
- PPO – premium $4,000 + out-of-pocket $4,000 = total $8,000
HDHP costs little less. In both cases, out-of-pocket expenses reached the maximum, so the plan took over the rest of expenses 100%.
(2) A family of 4 (2 adults, 2 young children) whose half of family need some medical services
- HDPD – premium $2,000 + out-of-pocket $1,700 = total $3,700
- PPO – premium $4,000 + out-of-pocket $300 = total $4,300
HDHP costs little less.
(3) A family of 2 adults who have small need of medical services e.g. just yearly checkup and flu shots
- HDPD – premium $1,200 + out-of-pocket $300 = total $1,500
- PPO – premium $2,400 + out-of-pocket $50 = total $2,450
Healthy family saves a lot from HDPD.
출처 https://introvertengineer.com/blog/2019/1/13/hdhp-hsa-vs-ppo